On Saturday 12 September Colin Poole and I performed a version of our duet “Colin, Simon & I” at The Place in London as part of the Touchwood season (designed to show works in various stages of development). We’d had about 7 weeks development (on and off), and there are some notes at

The final section of the work involves Colin moving to sit deep in the audience, and then me effectively trying to ‘fail’ as a performer. At least I think this is accurate. We’d cultivated a certain degree of awkwardness in how I was attempting to be, but of course things only stay awkward for so long. So, we didn’t really rehearse it at all. I was left talking (addressing the audience very directly) and dancing and attempting to find out (and share) what it was like to no longer have Colin on stage with me, and also talk to the feeling of wanting to entertain them (whilst trying to avoid doing just that).

Long silences. Long pauses. Flurries of movement. Some music (which made me feel more comfortable for sure). Discussing a slight feeling of frustration that Colin had elected to ‘disappear’, a monologue about how he hadn’t really disappeared … and then, a missed cue from the ushers. We thought they were going to ask the audience to leave whilst I was still attempting to fail. They didn’t and I was left with a really close experience of on stage awkwardness. Excellent fun indeed.

But what is it to fail on stage? The ‘dying’ I’d felt in an earlier showing wasn’t really there this time – it felt far too easy to go into ‘entertaining’ mode. Is it to not know what is going on? Is it resisting training/experience? How can I do this?

It reminds me of playing tennis as a youngster: when there were certain parts of my game that I was having trouble with, one strategy for coping with this would be to develop control of the failure. That is, to practice various degrees of failure (say, hitting the ball at the bottom of the net, then a bit higher, then a bit higher still, then to just touch the top, then to pass just over etc). It goes against all the rules in sport of “perfect practice makes perfect” but it was a powerful way of ‘owning’ the failure … or being able to choose to fail (and therefore choose to ‘succeed’).

As a performer/dancer, perhaps it is in listening to the silences and the stillnesses, and how audiences are ‘coping’ with these that can step the practice of failing into the foreground? Of course, the paradox is that seeking failure opens up the body to all kinds of listening that inevitable is not failing at all. Ugh.

I guess another question is about why I’d want to be failing … but in terms of this work with Colin it had to do with absence/presence on stage. That is, it was an aesthetic or creative decision.


2 Replies to “failure”

  1. bits and pieces…I remember doing a clowning workshop and one of the exercises was crossing the floor being invisible. It was done one at a time and with no set or props to hide it was very hard. At the moment I am doing a puppet show and as a lover of movement I am very particular about making my puppets move well. I feel like I fail onstage every time I misjudge the weight and timing of a puppet. I feel this even if the director hasn’t noticed.As a puppeteer the presence/absence question takes a different tack as whilst manipulating the puppet or object I become a backstage performer.Earlier this week I was telling some students about a very early theory of dance which breaks all dance into 2 main actions: scattering (opening) and gathering (closing). To fail is to close, crumple and fall. To succeed is to open, fill and lift.You are a very successful failure Simon.Much love.

  2. Hey Mr Jacob<br><br>Good to hear your thoughts. What you say about puppets is very interesting to me (with respect to the form-content of what Colin and I are were getting up to) … all sorts of possibilities there.<br><br> As for scattering/gathering – never hear about that. I think I really agree with the crumpling one … reminds me of trying to gather leaves in London's autumn – an impossible task, doomed to failure.<br><br>Thanks for vote of confidence – if I <i>ever</i> need pepping up you'll be 5th on my list.<br> <br>Oh, and it's really great to know that someone is reading this stuff.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s